Wondering which roof material is best? Slate and metal roofing materials have the ability to protect your home and offer different benefits.

Discover Which Roof Material Is Best

Discover Which Roof Material Is Best

If you’re planning to reroof a home, the materials you choose can have a huge impact on the home.

Cost of Roofing

A slate roof is going to come in with a high price tag for both the materials and the installation. When it comes to choosing the type of slate, there is a price range for homeowners to choose from, but even the least expensive option is often higher priced than other materials. In addition to what is needed for the roof, the labor is going to be considerable. If the roof has difficult-to-reach places or requires a little extra finesse in certain portions, the cost will continue to rise.

When compared to a slate roof, the metal roof cost is much more affordable. This is due in part to the cost of the materials. However, the installation cost is still going to be high. It is an intricate process that requires that all of the pieces fit together seamlessly to deliver the best results. After calculating the materials and the installation, you may want to take a closer look at some of the other differences between metal and slate before beginning a reroofing project.


Aesthetics - Slate Roof vs. Metal Roof

The look of a slate roof often draws in homeowners right away. There are several color and texture options to choose from. Part of the reason that the cost of slate is high is the attention taken in the making of each of every piece. Shingles can be shaped differently to meet the flow of the home and the curve of the roof. No matter what type of home you have, the slate roof will look great, adding an upscale look that complements the property.

A metal roof might not seem that appealing, but the metal can actually be made to mimic other materials, giving you some flexibility in the aesthetic of your roof. The metal has more color choices than slate and allows you to create a more customized look. Don’t let the look of a past metal roof deter you from taking a closer look at the possibilities. Remember that the metal roof cost is going to depend on what type of curb appeal you are trying to create with the materials, how they are laid, and what they look like on the structure.



There is a large difference in weight when comparing slate and metal roofing materials. Slate weighs a lot more. In some cases, when taking on a reroofing project, it becomes necessary to add some reinforcements to the structure of the home so that it can handle the weight of the slate. In fact, for homeowners in areas where some type of earthquake could take place, slate could be cause for concern. That is a lot of weight right over the heads of the residents of the space, and it could be a problem should any seismic activity take place.

A metal roof is much lighter. In fact, a slate roof on a larger home can weigh between 40 and 100 tons. The metal materials will only weight about 7 tons on the same size home. This is a huge difference to consider when weighing up which roof material is best. For some, the lighter weight offers a little extra peace of mind as they see the material as safer than some of the other options. If you need to look into reroofing, a metal roof can often be laid over top of an existing roof because it is so light, making the entire process a little easier with less wasted materials.


Because the roof isn’t an easy place to access, most homeowners are curious about the amount of maintenance their roofing materials are going to require. A metal roof is pretty much worry-free. They don’t tend to accumulate anything like moss or get leaves stuck in between the different pieces. If you choose materials like copper, you don’t need to worry about any type of fading. As an added bonus, they tend to be fire-resistant, giving them added durability.

A slate roof could have some problems down the road. Some can crack or become damaged when a person is walking around on the roof. While this may not be common, there could be areas of the roof that need to be accessed in order to work on other equipment. Unfortunately, moss can be a problem as it tends to sneak into the crevices and then thrive. For some people, the moss adds to the aesthetic, but in reality, this can lead to damage. Outside of these issues, there is no regular maintenance required and slate also offers a fire-resistant benefit. These considerations may impact which roof material is best for you.


Energy Efficiency

Today’s homeowners are often looking at energy efficiency before they make any big decisions. What is going to help the home cost less to heat in the summer and cool in the winter? Because the roof is going to see a lot of sun exposure, it could be the most important part of creating an energy-efficient home. This is really something to think about when it comes to reroofing. The savings should be figured in when calculating the cost of a new roof. Wondering which roof material is best when it comes to energy efficiency?

A slate roof is going to take in a lot of heat and then transfer it to the top of the home. While there are some ways to decrease the amount of heat that makes it into the living space, there is no doubt that your AC is going to need to work hard to combat the heat. A metal roof is completely different. Metal, when paired with a thermal liner, is one of the most energy-efficient options available. Some homeowners claim to have saved around 20 percent on their energy bills after the installation of a metal roof.

Energy Efficiency